Inside The Data, Outside The (Black) Box: Using Insights to Inform Your ESG Journey

Overview

Companies require in-depth analysis and insights that reveal their location on the ESG landscape vis-a-vis peers and competitors to guide key decisions for their sustainability journey. However, too often, these efforts rely on ESG scores and rankings.

The report identifies the challenges associated with using broad ESG scores and rankings, including lack of standardization, lack of transparency, and industry and geographical bias. The report advocates for an insights-based approach to ESG assessments, which goes beyond scores and offers a comprehensive understanding of a company's ESG strategy. It emphasizes transparency, context specificity, a 360° perspective, and user control over peer groups and material issues. The insights-based approach enables better benchmarking, better decision-making, and alignment with industry best practices.

Overall, the report emphasizes the importance of moving beyond superficial snapshots provided by ESG scores and embracing deeper analysis to unlock valuable insights for effective ESG benchmarking.

Correlations Across ESG Ratings

Research finds weak correlations across reported ESG scores from several major ESG rating providers. The widely differing interpretations and weighting of similarly reported data expose the diminished usefulness of scores in drawing valuable comparisons.

Source: Prall (2021)

Comparison of Two Software Companies

Differences and inconsistencies across ESG scores on the most fundamental questions can generate more questions than answers when trying to compare companies’ ESG standing. What is the correct takeaway? Which company is doing better? Scores may not be the answer.

Publication

Download the publication

Gain a competitive edge and stay informed about the latest industry trends by downloading our full publication.